A Tale of Two Streets

What is the difference between a street and a road?

Roads carry traffic from one place to another. When you make a journey by car, you should be on roads almost the entire time, the exceptions being when you set off from home, and when you arrive at your destination.

Streets are where people live, and the only traffic on them should be traffic that needs to be there – residents, visitors, deliveries.

So why is the phrase “rat run” so familiar in the UK?

A rat run is a street that is being used as a through-road. Most streets in the UK can be used like this, which is why children don’t play out in the street any more, as it’s highly likely that someone who has no business in the neighbourhood will be using the street as a short cut. This is the standard UK road design – but why?

Near my home there are two streets, and they’re very similar:

  • They are both residential streets (though one has many shops on too).
  • There are main roads to the North, South, and East.
  • They are connected directly to the road to the South.
  • They are connected the road road the East, very near to the junction with the road to the North.
  • They have a one-way street connecting them to the road to the East.

One of them is great to walk or ride along, but the other one can be horrible. One of them has hardly any traffic, the other is full of speeding taxis, motorbikes and vans.

Here’s why:

Hercules Road in London SE1, showing bad design which encourages rat-running

There is no restriction on traffic through the street here

As there is no restriction on traffic passing through the street, traffic heading from the North to the South-West (or vice-versa) can skip one set of traffic lights by using it as a rat-run, instead of keeping to the main through-roads.

Lower Marsh in London SE1, showing design which prevents rat-running.

Better design makes rat-running impossible, and the street is pleasant as a result

On this street just around the corner (I’ve kept the same layout for comparison) you can see that rat-running is impossible here, it doesn’t help you to use the street instead of the road. As a result, only vehicles who have reason to visit the street will do so.

The streets in question are Hercules Road and Lower Marsh, both in London SE1. Okay, so I kept the same layout for both streets, they’re not really quite as similar as that – Hercules Road has three one-way streets connecting to the West, whereas Lower Marsh has none any more, due to Waterloo station –  but they are very much the same in most important aspects.

Lower Marsh is pleasant to walk down, ride down, or even drive down, if you must! On how many streets in central London can a cat sit and wash?

A cat washing itself on Lower Marsh

Now this is what I call “shared space”!

Whereas Hercules Road isn’t even safe for fast cyclists, due to the aggressive rat-running, and also this awful pinch-point:

A nasty pinch-point on the rat run that is Hercules Road

I didn’t intentionally set out to get photos of taxis here, but they are very numerous! (Hercules Road is mainly residential, though the railway arches at the South-West end, seen in the background, are used as business units It’s also extremely wide at the Southern end.)

So here we have an example of good design, and bad design. Lower Marsh works, and there is no reason for Hercules Road to be a through-route for motor vehicles. Who do I get in touch with to look at this?

UPDATE, 29th of May 2012: I’ve been thinking about the options for Hercules Road (I do actually have that much time on my hands!) and a Lower Marsh-style solution won’t work, as it will still allow traffic heading North to rat-run around the traffic lights at the junction of Kennington Road and Lambeth Road. There’s tons of options, but I think the main point should be to remove the desire to use a street as a thoroughfare – a street should be a destination, not part of a route.

So, here’s one possible solution (I’ve added in a few more roads on this plan – all the one-way restrictions on these streets are already there):

Hercules Road, suggested motor traffic reduction scheme. Blocking motor traffic just south of the junction with Cosser Street will solve this.

Aah, I can see the cats sitting safely in the road now!

With this plan, the southern part of Hercules Road remains two-way. This is useful for the business units who rent space beneath the railway on the west side. (Luckily for the catering company which faces Cosser Street, they have a driveway on each side of the barrier!)

I’m not sure whether the top half of Hercules Road needs making one-way or not (probably does), but I’m certain that putting that motor vehicle restriction in place will remove the desire for using the street as a rat-run. Residents and businesses still have access, but the ability to skip the lights has gone.

I don’t know how much a few signs, a lick of paint and a concrete kerb cost, but I dare say it’s well within the budget of Lambeth Council to make Hercules Road into a street fit for those who live there.


Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “A Tale of Two Streets

  1. PaulM

    In case you were wondering about the delayed comment, it is because I have only just come across your blog, via your Biblical imprecation to John Franklin to go forth and multiply.

    There is probably a tendency to assume that rat-runs are a purely urban phenomenon, but let me give you one example (fortunately there are few) in leafy suburban Haslemere, Surrey, where I live.

    Beech Road (we don’t really have streets here, apart from High St and West St which is an almost unversal combination in any Surrey or Hampshire market town. We have roads and lanes) is a residential “street”. With one exception (in a mo) absolutely every single building along it is a dwelling house. Most are reasonably substantial detached properties – 4 bedrooms and at least a half-acre of garden – although at its southern end there are some higher density dwellings, semis and flats. By and large every resident can park at least one car in their own ground and off the road.

    The exception is that, in the space behind the houses and between Beech Road and Grayswood Road (the main A road heading north towards Guildford and London) is a GP’s surgery and a cottage hospital, and one of the two entrances to the combined site gives onto Beech Road.

    Beech Road is fairly narrow, certainly where cars are parked* it is not possible for two more cars to pass each other, and it can be tricky for a large vehicle like a delivery lorry to get through at all. It also has a quite tight bend half way along and a few kinks with poor sight lines.

    This is not an obvious place for a rat run because the traffic is really not very dense, even at peak times, and there are no traffic lights apart from a pedestrian crossing about a quarter-mile further down the road in the High Street, and no measurable queuing.

    This does not however stop the impatient from trying to shave a handful of econds off their journey by ratting down (southwards) Beech Road, or occasionally up (the junction with the main road is trickier in the northbound direction) in order to avoid having to wait while a preceding car waits at a crossroads just further down the main road, to turn left across oncoming traffic. There is not much ratting, but what there is, is fast, so the kids are never seen on the street.

    *Car parking is also a terrible curse of this street, mainly due to the hospital and health centre, neither of which has adequate off-road parking for its size. And of course no-one is prepared to park a quarter mile away in a borough car park and walk up. You do wonder how many of the cases the doctors see are obesity related!

  2. Pingback: Pretend infrastructure | The Alternative Department for Transport

  3. Pingback: Vorgetäuschte Infrastruktur | Das andere Bundesministerium für Verkehr

  4. alec fitz

    I most heartly agree with your problem. I live in a rat run road in b263yf Birmingham this road is a nightmare .we have a main school on its route cars etc do in excess of 50-60 mph small children ate at risk all the time and so are people in the road.the council say they may fit warning signs for 20 mph I wont hold my breath.so on Will get injured sooner or later.

Leave a reply...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s